Do your prayers for unbelievers resemble this prayer at all?
Matthew Henry’s Prayer for Unbelievers (This is a very good resource on Prayer.)
O teach transgressors your ways, and let sinners return to you. Psalm 51:13 (ESV)
O give them repentance leading to a knowledge of the truth, 2 Timothy 2:25 (ESV) the truth as it is in Jesus, Ephesians 4:21 (ESV) the truth which accords with godliness, Titus 1:1 (ESV) that they may come to their senses and escape from the snare of the devil. 2 Timothy 2:26 (ESV)
Let those who are straying like sheep return to Jesus Christ, the Shepherd and Overseer of our souls. 1 Peter 2:25 (ESV)
Show those fools their folly and misery who have said in their hearts, “There is no God,” and who are corrupt and do abominable deeds. Psalm 14:1 (ESV)
Lord, maintain the honor of the Scriptures, the teaching and the testimony, and convince those who speak not according to that word, that it is because they have no dawn. Isaiah 8:20 (ESV) You have exalted above all things your name and your word; Psalm 138:2 (ESV) magnify the law, magnify the gospel, and make both glorious. Isaiah 42:21 (ESV)
Let those who will not be won by the word, be won by the conduct of Christians, 1 Peter 3:1 (ESV) which we beg may be such in everything that those who do not believe may be convicted by all and called to account by all, may be brought to worship God and to declare that God is really among them. 1 Corinthians 14:24-25 (ESV)